When “I Don’t Know” Means You’re Asking the Wrong Question by Don Elium MFT
In relationships, few things feel more frustrating than bringing your heart to someone and hearing, “I don’t know.” However, this response often doesn’t indicate evasion or a lack of care—it signals a problem with the question itself. Especially in emotionally charged moments, the wrong question can push someone into a corner, shut down the conversation, or demand clarity where there’s only confusion. In contrast, a better question—grounded in curiosity, not accusation—can open a doorway to new connections, understanding, and change.
Great brainstorming is built on this principle: when you're stuck, change the question. Good questions shift perspectives, invite vulnerability, and create space for exploration. Sometimes, that means asking the so-called “dumb” question. Other times, it requires rephrasing the “smart” one with more heart. But always, it's about staying sincerely curious. The aim isn't a quick fix—it's discovery. When the right question lands, it's like turning on a light in a dim room. Suddenly, you can see what has been there all along.
This shift in questioning also reflects the difference between first-order and second-order change. A first-order change addresses symptoms: “Let's spend more time together.” This approach is helpful but often temporary. A second-order change tackles the root: “What helps us feel close even when life is busy?” These deeper questions may not always have easy answers, but they often spark insights that change everything—not just behavior but the underlying dynamics.
To clarify the difference, let's examine “wrong” questions that tend to elicit “I don’t know” along with more fruitful alternatives.
When you're stuck, change the question.
Wrong question: “Why don't you love me like you used to?”
Better question: “What helps you feel most loved by me these days?”
Wrong question: “What's wrong with you?”
Better question: “What's been feeling heavy or hard for you lately?”
Wrong question: “Can't you just be happy?”
Better question: “What would feeling more joy together look like right now?” Do you see the shift?
Wrong question: “Why are you always so moody lately?”
Better question: “What’s been overwhelming or different for you these days?”
Wrong question: “Why don’t you talk to me anymore?”
Better question: “What makes you feel safe or open when we talk?”
Wrong question: “Why don’t you ever come visit us?”
Better question: “What kind of time together feels easiest or most enjoyable for you right now?”
Wrong question: “Why did you stop texting back?”
Better question: “Has anything been making it hard to stay connected lately?”
Wrong question: “Why am I always the one who reaches out?”
Better question: “What does staying in touch look like for you today?”
Wrong question: “Why don’t we hang out like we used to?”
Better question: “What kind of moments or experiences bring you alive in friendships now?”
————
The wrong questions inadvertently signal blame or pressure. The better questions invite exploration and care. When people feel safe and seen, they tend to find their words. The “I don't know” softens into a thoughtful pause, a complete sentence, and something genuine.
So, the next time you encounter a relational wall, don't just repeat the question louder. Change it. Make it more generous, more curious, and more open. The right question doesn't demand an answer—it helps someone find their own. Often, that's when a new conversation begins.